Traffic effects on soil compaction and sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) taproot quality parameters

Francesco Marinello, Andrea Pezzuolo, Donato Cillis, Alessandro Chiumenti, Luigi Sartori


Soil compaction is a critical issue in agriculture having a significant influence on crop growth. Sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) is accounted as a crop susceptible to compaction. Reduction of leaf area, final yield, and root quality parameters are reported in compacted soils. The most obvious visual indicator of topsoil compaction is root depth affected by agricultural tractor and machinery traffic up on the soil. Such indicators are mainly correlated to initial soil condition, tyre features, and number of passages. Monitoring and controlling frequency and position of machine traffic across the field, in such a way that passages are completed on specific, well-defined tracks, can assist with minimization of compaction effects on soil. The objective of the present work was to analyze the subsoil compaction during the growing period of sugar beet with different farming approaches including controlled traffic passages and random traffic. To this end, tests were carried out following each agro technical operation using penetrometer readings in order to monitor the state of cone-index after each step. In addition, at the harvesting time, root quality parameters were analyzed with particular attention to length and regularity of the taproot, total length, circumference, mass, and above-ground biomass. Such parameters were usefully implemented in order to evaluate the effects of controlled traffic passages compared to the random traffic in a cultivation of sugar beet. Results highlight how an increase in crop yield, derived from samples monitored, higher than 10% can be expected with implementation of a careful traffic management.


soil; traffic management; compaction; crop parameters

Full Text:



Ansorge D, Godwin RJ, 2007. The effect of tyres and a rubber track at high axle loads on soil compaction, Part 1: single axle-studies. Biosyst Eng 98: 115-126.

Ansorge D, Godwin RJ, 2008. The effect of tyres and a rubber track at high axle loads on soil compaction, Part 2: multi-axle machine studies. Biosyst Eng 99: 338-347.

ASAE, 2001. EP542: Procedures for using and reporting data obtained with the soil cone penetrometer, 48th edition. Am Soc Agric Biol Eng, St. Joseph, MI, USA.

Ayers PD, Bowen HD, 1987. Predicting soil density using cone penetration resistance and moisture profiles. T ASABE 30: 1331-1336.

Balbuena R, Botta GF, Draghi L, Rosatto H, Dagostino C, 2003. Soil compaction. Tractor traffic effects on direct sowing systems. Span J Agric Res 1 (2): 75-80.

Basso B, Dumont B, Cammarano D, Pezzuolo A, Marinello F, Sartori L, 2016. Environmental and economic benefits of variable rate nitrogen fertilization in a nitrate vulnerable zone. Sci Total Env (545-546): 227-235.

Botta GF, Jorajuria D, Draghi LM, 2002. Influence of the axle load, tyre size and configuration on the compaction of a freshly tilled clayey soil. J Terramechanics 39: 47-54.

Brereton JC, McGowan M, Dawkins TCK, 1986. The relative sensitivity of spring barley, spring field beans and sugar beet crops to soil compaction. Field Crops Res 13/C: 223-237.

Chamen T, 2006. Controlled traffic farming: literature review and appraisal of potential use in the U.K. HGCA Research Review.

Chamen T, Chittey ET, Leede PR, Goss MJ, Howse KR, 1990. The effect of tyre soil contact pressure and zero traffic on soil and crop responses when growing winter wheat. J Agr Eng Res 47: 1-21.

Chamen WCT, Vermeulen GD, Campbell DJ, Sommer C, 1992. Reduction of traffic-induced soil compaction - A synthesis. Soil Till Res 24: 303-318.

Chancellor WC, 1976. Compaction of soil by agricultural equipment. Div. Agric. Sci., Univ. of California, Davies, Bull., 1881.

Chen H, Yang Y, 2015. Effect of controlled traffic system on machine fuel saving in annual twocrops region in North China Plain. Soil Till Res 153: 137-144.

Chukuw E, Bowers JCG, 2005. Instantaneous multiple-depth soil mechanical impedance sensing from a moving vehicle. T ASABE 48: 885-894.

Da Silva AP, Kay BD, 1996. The sensitivity of shoot growth of corn to the least limiting water range of soils. Plant Soil 184: 323-329.

Gasso V, Sørensen CAG., Oudshoorn FW, Green O, 2013. Controlled traffic farming: A review of the environmental impacts. Eur J Agron 48: 66-73.

Gemtos TA, Lellis T, 1997. Effects of soil compaction, water and organic matter contents on emergence and initial plant growth of cotton and sugar beet. J Agr Eng Res 66: 121-134.

Gemtos TA, Goulas C, Lellis T, 2000. Sugar beet genotype response to soil compaction stress. Eur J Agron 12: 201-209.

Hall HE, Raper RL, 2005. Development and concept evaluation of an on-the-go soil strength measurement system. T ASABE 48: 469-477.

Hamza MA, Anderson WK, 2005. Soil compaction in cropping systems: a review of the nature, causes and possible solutions. Soil Till Res 82/2: 121-145.

Hemmat A, Adamchuk VI, Jasa P, 2008. Use of an instrumented disc coulter for mapping soil mechanical resistance. Soil Till Res 98: 150-163.

Hemmat A, Khorsandy A, Masoumi AA, Adamchuk VI, 2009. Influence of failure mode induced by a horizontally operated single-tip penetrometer on measured soil resistance. Soil Till Res 105: 49-54.

Holpp M, Anken T, Sauter M, Rek J, Reiser R, Zihlmann U, Oberholzer HR, Weisskopf P, Hensel O, 2011. Swiss controlled traffic farming trial - Preliminary results 2008-2010. 8th Eur Conf on Precision Agriculture, pp: 312-323.

Hummel JW, Ahmad IS, Newman SC, Sudduth KA, Drummond ST, 2004. Simultaneous soil moisture and cone index measurement. T ASAE 47: 607-618.

Kenter C, Hoffmann CM, Märländer B, 2006. Effects of weather variables on sugar beet yield development. (Beta vulgaris L.). Eur J Agron 24: 62-69.

Kiymaz S, Ertek A, 2015. Yield and quality of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) at different water and nitrogen levels under the climatic conditions of Kırsehir, Turkey. Agr Water Manage 158: 156-165.

Koch HJ, Heuer H, Tomanová O, Märländer B, 2008.Cumulative effect of annually repeated passes of heavy agricultural machinery on soil structural properties and sugar beet yield under two tillage systems. Soil Till Res 101: 69-77.

Kroulík M, Kvíz Z, Kumhála F, Hůla J, Loch T, 2011. Procedures of soil farming allowing reduction of compaction. Precis Agric 12 (3): 317-333.

Kumar D, Chen Y, Sadek A, Rahman S, 2012. Soil cone index in relation to soil texture, moisture content, and bulk density for no-tillage and conventional tillage. CIGR J 14: 1-16.

López-Garrido R, Dìaz-Espejo A, Madejón E, Murillo JM, Moreno F, 2009. Carbon losses by tillage under semi-arid Mediterranean rainfed agriculture (SW Spain). Span J Agric Res 7 (3): 706-716.

Märländer B, Tijink FGJ, Hoffman C, Beckers R (Eds.), 1998. Soil compaction and compression in relation to sugar beet production. Advances in Sugar Beet Research, vol. 1. IIRB, Brussels, 103 pp.

Martín-Lammerding D, Tenorio JL, Albarrán MM, Zambrana E, Walter I. 2013. Influence of tillage practices on soil biologically active organic matter content over a growing season under semiarid Mediterranean climate. Span J Agric Res 11 (1): 232-243.

McHugh AD, Tullberg JN, Freebairn DM, 2009. Controlled traffic farming restores soil structure. Soil Till Res 104: 164-172.

McPhee JE, Aird PL, Hardie MA, Corkrey SR, 2015. The effect of controlled traffic on soil physical properties and tillage requirements for vegetable production. Soil Till Res 149: 33-45.

Mosimann T, Sanders S, Brunotte J, 2007. Erosion reduction in tractor tracks - The effects of intermittent planting in tractor tracks of wheat and sugar beet fields with different soil cultivation. Pflanzenbauwissenschaften 11 (2): 57-66.

Pezzuolo A, Basso B, Marinello F, Sartori L, 2014. Using SALUS model for medium and long term simulations of energy efficiency in different tillage systems. Appl Math Sci 8: 129-132.

Pezzuolo A, Dumont B, Sartori L, Marinello F, De Antoni Migliorati M, Basso B, 2017. Evaluating the impact of soil conservation measures on soil organic carbon at the farm scale. Comput Electron Agr 135: 175-182.

Tolon-Becerra A, Lastra-Bravo XB, Botta GF, Tourn M, Linares P, Ressia M, Balbuena R. 2011. Traffic effect on soil compaction and yields of wheat in Spain. Span J Agric Res 9 (2): 395-403.

Valdes-Abellan J, Jiménez-Martínez J, Candela L, Tamoh K, 2015. Comparison among monitoring strategies to assess water flow dynamic and soil hydraulic properties in agricultural soils. Span J Agric Res 13 (1): e12-001.

DOI: 10.5424/sjar/2017151-8935