Growth stage of Phalaris minor Retz. and wheat determines weed control and crop tolerance of four post-emergence herbicides

Rubia Rasool, Makhan S. Bhullar, Gurjeet S. Gill


Phalaris minor Retz. has evolved multiple herbicide resistance in wheat growing areas in northwestern India. An understanding of the effect of growth stage on herbicide tolerance of wheat and control of P. minor will help in selecting the most appropriate herbicide for different situations. The weed control and crop safety of four commonly used wheat herbicides (sulfosulfuron, pinoxaden, fenoxaprop plus metribuzin and mesosulfuron plus iodosulfuron), each applied at four different wheat growth stages was investigated in field studies for two years. P. minor plants were at 1, 2-3, 3-4 and 7-8 leaf stages when the herbicides were applied at Zadok 12-Z12, Z13, Z21 and Z23 stages of wheat, respectively. Sulfosulfuron application at Z12 and Z13 wheat stages (before first irrigation), provided >80% control of P. minor and produced wheat grain yield (4.5-4.7 t/ha) similar to the weed-free check (4.9 t/ha) in both years. Pinoxaden, fenoxaprop plus metribuzin and mesosulfuron plus iodosulfuron application at Z12 and Z13 wheat stages recorded significantly lower wheat grain yield (3.62-3.95 t/ha) due to poor weed control, crop toxicity or both. All the four herbicides were equally effective on P. minor when applied at Z21 wheat stage. At Z23 wheat stage, pinoxaden gave >90% control of P. minor and the highest wheat grain yield (4.82 t/ha). The results are expected to allow changes in the current recommendation of the timing of post-emergence herbicides for the management of P. minor in wheat.


crop toxicity; crop stages; littleseed canarygrass; selectivity; Triticum aestivum

Full Text:



AICRPWM, 2013. Annual Technical Report of All India Coordinated Research Project on Weed Management. Punjab Agric. Univ., Dept. Agron., Ludhiana, India, 100 pp.

Balyan RS, 1999. Efficacy of sulfosulfuron, tralkoxydim and metribuzin applied alone and tank-mix on weeds in wheat. Indian J Weed Sci 31: 80-83.

Bhullar MS, Punia SS, Tomar SS, Singh VP, Sharma JD, 2014. Littleseed canarygrass resistance to clodinafop in Punjab: Farmers' perspective. Indian J Weed Sci 46: 237-240.

Bhullar MS, Pandey M, Kumar S, Gill G, 2016. Weed management in conservation agriculture in India. Indian J Weed Sci 48: 1-12.

Blackshaw RE, Moyer JR, Kozub GC, 1994. Efficacy of downy brome herbicides as influenced by soil properties. Can J Plant Sci 74: 177-183.

Chhokar RS, Malik RK, 2002. Isoproturon resistant Phalaris minor and its response to alternate herbicides. Weed Technol 16: 116-123.[0116:IRLCPM]2.0.CO;2

Chhokar RS, Sharma RK, Chauhan DS, Mongia AD, 2006. Evaluation of herbicides against Phalaris minor in wheat in northwestern Indian plains. Weed Res 46: 40-49.

Chhokar RS, Singh S, Sharma RK, 2008. Herbicides for control of isoproturon-resistant littleseed canarygrass (Phalaris minor) in wheat. Crop Prot 27: 719-726.

Crooks HL, York AC, Jordan DL, 2003. Wheat tolerance and Italian ryegrass control by AE F130060 00 plus AE F115008 08 mixed with other herbicides. Weed Technol 17: 881-889.

Crooks HL, York AC, Jordan DL, 2004. Wheat tolerance to AE F130060 00 plus AE F115008 00 as affected by time of application and rate of the safener AE F107892. Weed Technol 18: 841-845.

Das TK, 2014. Herbicide selectivity in plants-Weed science: Basics and applications, 1st Edn. Jain Brothers, New Delhi, 438 pp.

Dhawan RS, Bhaskar P, Chawla S, 2010. Effect of pinoxaden on the seedling growth and chlorophyll development of the fenoxaprop-p-ethyl susceptible and resistant biotypes of P. minor and wheat. Indian J Weed Sci 42: 52-55.

Grey TL, Bridges DC, 2003. Alternatives to diclofop for the control of Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum) in winter wheat (Triticum aestivum). Weed Technol 17:219-223.[0219:ATDFTC]2.0.CO;2

Grey TL, Cutts GS, Sosnoskie L, Culpepper AS, 2012. Italian ryegrass (Lolium perenne) control and winter wheat response to POST herbicides. Weed Technol 26: 644-648.

Hofer U, Muehlebach M, Hole S, Zoschke A, 2006. Pinoxaden- for broad spectrum grass weed management in cereal crops. J Plant Dis Prot 20: 989-995.

Kaur N, Kaur T, Kaur S, Bhullar MS, 2016. Development of cross resistance in Phalaris minor Retz. in Punjab. Agric Res J 53: 69-72.

Kieloch R, Domaradzaki K, Gornial J, 2006. Pinoxaden -a new active ingredient for grass weed control in cereals of South-West Poland. J Plant Dis Prot 20: 1067-1072.

Kleeman SGL, Gill GS, 2008. Applications of metribuzin for the control of rigid brome (Bromus rigidus) in no-till barley crops of Southern Australia. Weed Technol 22: 34-37.

Lemerle D, Hinkley RB, Kidd CR, Leys AR, 1986. Symptoms of injury caused by herbicides in wheat and barley. Advisory Bull (Dept. Agriculture, New South Wales) 4: 1-14.

Levy SJ, 2008. Environmental Protection Agency's records disposition schedule PEST 361 scientific data reviews HED (health effects division) records center - File R158148, 5 pp.

Runyan TJ, Mcneil WK, Peeper TF, 1982. Differential tolerance of wheat cultivars to metribuzin. Weed Sci 30: 94-97.

SAS, 2001. SAS User's Guide. SAS Institute, Cary, NC (USA).

Schroeder J, Banks PA, Nichols RL, 1986. Soft red winter wheat (Triticum aestivum) cultivar response to metribuzin. Weed Sci 34: 66-69.

Senseman SA, 2007. Herbicide handbook, 9th Edn. Am Weed Sci Soc, Champaign, IL, USA, 458 pp.

Shaner DL, 2014. Sulfosulfuron. In: Herbicide handbook, 10th Edn. Am Weed Sci Soc, Champaign, IL, USA. pp: 427-428.

Shaw DR, Wesley MT, 1991. Wheat (Triticum aestivum) cultivar tolerance and Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum) control with Diclofop, BAY SMY 1500, and metribuzin. Weed Technol 5: 776-781.

Singh G, Singh VP, Singh M, Singh RK, 2003. Effect of doses and stages of application of sulfosulfuron on weeds and wheat yield. Indian J Weed Sci 35: 183-185.

Singh S, Kirkwood RC, Marshall G, 1999. Biology and control of Phalaris minor Retz. (littleseed canarygrass) in wheat. Crop Prot 18: 1-16.

Singh S, Singh S, Sharma SD, Punia SS, Singh H, 2005. Performance of tank mixture of metribuzin with clodinafop and fenoxaprop for the control of mixed weed flora in wheat. Indian J Weed Sci 37: 9-12.

Singh S, Singh K, Punia SS, Yadav A, Dhawan RS, 2011. Effect of stage of Phalaris minor on the efficacy of Accord plus (fenoxaprop+metsulfuron, readymix). Indian J Weed Sci 43: 23-31.

Tickes B, 2000. Evaluation of herbicides for the control of littleseed canarygrass in wheat. Forage and grain report. University of Arizona, College of Agriculture and Life Sciences.

Tottman DR, 1980. Varietal differences in the tolerance of cereals to herbicides. Winter Wheat, Crop Conference, p. 68.

Yuan X, Guo P, Qi X, Ning N, Wang H, Wang X, Yang Y, 2013. Safety of herbicide Sigma Broad on Radix isatidis (Isatis indigotica Fort.) seedlings and their photosynthetic physiological responses. Pestic Biochem Physiol 106: 45-50.

Zadoks JC, Chang TT, Konzak CF, 1974. A decimal code for the growth stages of cereals. Weed Res 14: 415-421.

DOI: 10.5424/sjar/2017151-9728